Wednesday 26 September 2012

Preliminary Task - Evaluating Photos

By Emma Hall

Best Photographs:

 I chose this photograph as one of my best as the framing of the shot means model is the focus of the photo, and the tickets are in the centre of the page and so can be clearly visible. There is also adequate amount of space down the right hand side for my text, and the tickets are raised high enough to allow for my subheading along the bottom. Also, the building is positioned so that there is a gap in the top right hand corner, where my masthead can go. The sun is also coming in from the right of the photo, meaning the face is well lit, but the model doesn't have to squint. There are also trees out of shot which provide a shadow on the ground down the right side, which provide a nice plain background for where my text will go and will mean they will be more easily legible. The use of the location being the college in the background also means the college, whose magazine it is, gets featured on the front page. Being outside on a nice day, also means it looks sunny, and the school appears in a good, appealing way. However, the college does not relate directly to the main article, and as the model is wearing a bag and has the tickets in her hand, it feels like she is about to set off into  the Exhibition, so the background location should ideally be a museum. However, due to the availability of locations locally, the college does fit the job alright, as the model is supposed to be representing her college.


This photograph is not quite as good as the first, but is still quite good, as the way the tree over hangs at the top of the shot makes a nice frame and forces the viewer's focus onto the tickets. The model also has a pleasant smile and is looking directly at the camera, and appears more relaxed and natural than on the first photograph. The school can also be seen in the background, highlighted by the sunshine, which shows it in a positive light. However, the shade of the tree means the model's face is not lit up very well, as the sun has come down through the leaves to make a strange pattern across her face. Although it is quite a dark photograph in general, the dark tree branch across the top of the shot makes a nice base for my banner and masthead to  go over, as they follow the same horizontal path. The use of the tree does not relate to the article much, but the framing of the tree in this photograph means the tickets (which are relevant) are clearly visible.


The brightness of the light in this photograph make s it one of my best, as it means the colours of the sky and grass are really beautiful and bright, in an almost fairytale kind of way. The model is also quite clearly lit, but it may be that it is slightly too bright, as the left side of her face is slightly in shadow.the tickets are also clearly visible, but don't leave much space down the right hand side for the text. The base of green will let the text show up well, though, as will the masthead. The horizon line in the background is also nearly horizontal and so will match the horizontal path of the banner at the top. The school however, may not be visibile once the masthead and text are put on, but the shot as it is works well as the school and the tickets on the right balance out the model on the left. The model does appear less relaxed in this shot, but still appears happy and is the focus of the viewer's eye.

Worst Photographs: 

This photograph isn't very good, as the model, primarily is on the wrong side to how I planned for my shoot, and has her eyes closed against the sun. The light is also on the wrong side of her, meaning only the top of her face is lit, and the rest, including the tickets, is in darkness. There are also too many colours and objects down the left side which means any writing would have a hard time being read. The school is also in the way of where my masthead would be and so would be covered up.  The wind is also blowing the model's air slightly wild, and the way the tickets are held is a bit awkward. The angle of the camera also means she is leant slightly out of shot. Other than that, the overall balance of the shot is good, with the school on the right balancing the model on the left.


The lighting on this photograph is alright, but the left of the model's face is slightly in shadow, but other than that, the model is well lit. However the pose the model is pulling does not look professional, and the photo was took at the wrong time and caught the wrong expression.The tickets are also held in a manner which doesn't display them very well. There is also not much to see in the background, and the location could be anywhere, without much relevance to the cover story.


This picture isn't very effective as the model isn't looking at the camera, which makes her pose with the tickets look slightly random. She is also having to squint slightly into the sun. The shot is also quite a close mid-shot, and so the model fills most of the left hand side and so doesn't leave much room for a banner at the top. However, the closer shot means the writing on the tickets is legible, though they are held at an awkward angle, and will impede on the reading of the text down the right side, as will the school building. The light is coming in at a good angle to light up the model's face though, and the background location looks really sunny and bright.



No comments:

Post a Comment